
First a warning. I'm going to ruin the movie for you. So if you haven't seen it, and you want to see it, you might want to stop reading, and come back when you've seen it. If you've read the book, you'll understand this better, and I won't be ruining anything for you. And if you've ever owned a dog for it's entire life, I really won't ruin it for you. Ready?
Are you sure you don't want to quit reading? I'll wait while you decide...
Ok...time's up.
Overall I think they did a good job with this movie. This is going to sound like a negative review, but I really did enjoy the movie. Very similar to the book, actually almost exactly, except for some parts they left out. But they have to do that. Not enough time. It was much longer than I expected, and by then end, much longer than I wanted it to be.
For the first 15-20 minutes everyone in the theatre was laughing until they cried. Then there came the part where their first pregnancy failed. You could hear a pin drop in that theatre during that scene. And then some woman's phone rang. Seriously people. The screen tells you like 10 times to turn your phone OFF. Totally ruined the moment.
After that it wasn't very funny. Parts of it were, but the real humor was whisked out of the room with the scene when they got home from the hospital. Then it became too real.
One part I particularly liked was about a minute or two long, where John quickly narrated about a year of their lives. Made for a quick way to get through about half of the book. They should've done it one other time, just to save some time. One important thing they left out was the bond between John and Marley. In the book they seemed to be BFF's. A man and his dog. Totally didn't feel that in the movie.
They did a great job depicting Marley and the terror that he was. I do have one issue though. I read that they used like 22 dogs in the filming. During the puppy stages that was fine, but when he got older, you could totally tell every time the dog changed. Different nose, eyes and color on every one. I couldn't get past that for some reason.
Jennifer Anniston and Owen Wilson were perfect for their parts. This is NOT a kid's movie. And there were LOTS of kids in the theatre. The puppies/dogs are cute, but there are quite a few suggestive scenes that I don't consider appropriate for anyone under 16. Even then I'd be wary, but you can't shelter them from everything!
***SPOILER ALERT!!!!***
Marley dies in the end. I thought they dragged out the dying scenes for about 5 minutes too long. Made it uncomfortable just waiting for him to die. And I think they actually killed (euthanized) the dog they used in the death scene - he looked very old. Either that or it was some really good camera work, because he wasn't breathing after he 'went to sleep.'
Overall it was a good film. Not necessary to see it in the theatre. Save your money and your dignity and rent it, so you can boo-hoo in peace. Because you will boo-hoo. If you don't, I'd check for a pulse.
John asked a poignant question at the end...he was reminiscing about Marley, and how wonderful it was to have him in his life...(and don't totally quote me on this)...but think about it...
"When's the last time a person made you feel raw emotion? Made you feel pure, simple, extraordinary?"
I came home and took Tas for a run at the park, then spooned with him on the couch while he slept. And I cried.